How to calculate marginal costs and benefits (from total costs and benefits), and how to use that information to calculate equilibrium

This example problem goes over the degree of comfort experienced at different levels of clean air.  The different dollar value amounts are shown for every 10% increase in clean air.  We want to find the optimum amount of clean air that we should have in this area, and it is important to remember that there is an optimal amount of pollution.  Having 100% clean air is probably never going to be the solution.

So the first step is to recognize the type of data we are working with.  In this problem we have a table of information showing us what the benefits and costs are for different levels of clean air. 

As we would expect, the more clean air we have in our economy, the higher the benefit we receive (we prefer clean air over dirty air).  However, as we produce (or clean) more of the clean air we also incur a cost.  As more clean air is present, the higher our costs. Note that benefits here is the same as utility,

% of Clean Air	Total Benefits	Total Cost
0%	0	0
10%	50	45
20%	130	50
30%	205	58
40%	269	68
50%	319	81
60%	351	96
70%	371	115
80%	386	150
90%	398	200
100%	406	280

The next logical step is to calculate the marginal benefits (marginal utility), and marginal costs.  In order to do this we should begin at 0% clean air.  When we move to 10% clean air, we see that benefits go up by 50, and costs go up by 45.  This means that our marginal benefit from 10% clean air is 50, and our marginal cost of 10% clean air is 45.  When we move from 10% to 20% we see total benefit change from 50 to 130.  This means that marginal benefit from another 10% increase in clean air (from 10% to 20%) is 80 (130-50).  The increase in cost is 5 (50-45) which is also our marginal cost.  We can do these calculations all the way through and we will end up with the following table:

% of Clean Air	Total Benefits	Total Cost	Marginal Benefits	Marginal Cost
0%	0	0
10%	50	45	50	45
20%	130	50	80	5
30%	205	58	75	8
40%	269	68	64	10
50%	319	81	50	13
60%	351	96	32	15
70%	371	115	20	19
80%	386	150	15	35
90%	398	200	12	50
100%	406	280	8	80

You can see that marginal costs are rising as more clean air is produced, and that marginal benefits are decreasing as more clean air is produced.  This result is consistent with the theory of diminishing marginal utility (for marginal benefits), and diminishing marginal returns (for increasing marginal costs).

If we graph out the marginal costs and marginal benefits, we will get our typical looking supply and demand graph where marginal costs represent supply (supply of c lean air) and marginal benefits represent demand (demand for clean air).

Now there are two ways to find the optimum amount of clean air.  The most basic economic way is to figure out where marginal benefits equal marginal costs.  In our table above, they are never perfectly equal, but at 70% clean air, we see that marginal benefit is 20, and marginal cost is 19.  This is pretty close, and since MB are greater than MC then this is a valid solution.  The true answer will probably be around 71% but 70$ is pretty close. 

Another way to do it is to find the difference between total benefits and total costs and choose the biggest number.  Theoretically either method will give us the same result so let’s find out:

% of Clean Air	Total Benefits	Total Cost	Net Benefit
0%	0	0	0
10%	50	45	5
20%	130	50	80
30%	205	58	147
40%	269	68	201
50%	319	81	238
60%	351	96	255
70%	371	115	256
80%	386	150	236
90%	398	200	198
100%	406	280	126

As you can see, our 70% clean air level gives us the highest net benefit.  Although it is only 1 higher than the 60% clean air level, it is higher.  This result is consistent with our MB = MC analysis so we should be confident that 70% clean air is the correct amount for this economy.